Providing Out-of-Band Connectivity to Mission-Critical IT Resources

SD-WAN Management Guide

SD-WAN Management Platform

SD-WAN applies software-defined networking (SDN) principles to wide area networks (WANs), which means it decouples networking logic from the underlying WAN hardware. SD-WAN management involves orchestrating and optimizing software-defined WAN workflows across the entire architecture, ideally from a single, centralized platform. This SD-WAN management guide explains how this technology works, the potential benefits of using it, and the best practices to help you get the most out of your SD-WAN deployment.

How does SD-WAN management work?

A typical WAN architecture uses a variety of links, including MPLS, wireless, broadband, and VPNs, to connect branches and other remote locations to enterprise applications and resources. SD-WAN is a virtualized service that overlays this physical architecture, giving software teams a unified software interface from which to manage network traffic and workflows across the enterprise. SD-WAN management decouples network control functions from the gateways and routers installed at remote sites, preventing administrators from having to manage each one individually. It also reduces the reliance on manual CLI rules and prompts, which are time-consuming and prone to human error, allowing teams to deploy policies across an entire network at the same time.

SD-WAN can also use multiple connection types (including 5G LTE, MPLS, and fiber) interchangeably, switching between them as needed to ensure optimal performance. Plus, SD-WAN management enables organizations to use virtualized and cloud-based security technologies (such as SASE) to secure remote traffic to SaaS, web, and cloud resources. This allows organizations to reduce traffic on expensive MPLS links by utilizing less-costly cellular and public internet links to handle cloud-destined traffic.

The benefits of SD-WAN management

SD-WAN Benefit

Description

Branch bandwidth cost reduction

SD-WAN reduces bandwidth costs by redirecting cloud- and internet-destined traffic across less expensive channels, reserving the MPLS link for enterprise traffic alone

Branch performance optimization

SD-WAN management uses technologies like application awareness and guaranteed minimum bandwidth to automatically optimize network performance

Branch automation & orchestration

SD-WAN’s software-based management enables automatic deployments, load balancing, failover, and intelligent routing with a centralized orchestrator

Branch security enhancement

SD-WAN enables the use of cloud-based security solutions like SASE and Zero Trust Edge that extend enterprise security controls to branch network traffic

Cost reduction

MPLS links provide a secure connection between branches and centralized data center resources, but the bandwidth is far more expensive than fiber or cellular. SD-WAN reduces branch bandwidth costs by using less expensive channels for traffic that’s destined for resources online and in the cloud, reserving MPLS bandwidth for enterprise traffic alone.

Improved performance

To optimize the performance of a traditional WAN, teams must create specific routing, bandwidth utilization, and load-balancing rules for each branch and appliance, and hope these policies adequately predict and resolve any potential issues. SD-WAN management uses technologies like application awareness and guaranteed minimum bandwidth to automatically optimize network performance.

Automation & orchestration

By decoupling network control functions from the underlying WAN hardware, SD-WAN enables automatic device deployments, load balancing, failover, and intelligent routing. Teams can orchestrate automated workflows across the entire network architecture from a centralized software platform, to make deployments and configuration changes more efficient.

Enhanced security

Branch networks often suffer from security gaps due to the difficulty in extending enterprise security policies and controls to remote sites. Securing branch traffic usually means backhauling all traffic through the data center’s firewall, eating up expensive MPLS bandwidth and introducing latency for the rest of the enterprise. Some organizations opt to deploy security appliances at each branch site, which is costly and gives network administrators more moving parts to manage. 

SD-WAN enables the use of cloud-based security solutions like SASE and Zero Trust Edge that extend enterprise security defenses to branch network traffic without backhauling or additional hardware. SD-WAN automatically identifies traffic destined for web or cloud resources and routes it through the cloud-based security stack across less-expensive internet links, saving money and reducing management complexity while improving branch security.

How to get the most out of your SD-WAN deployment

There are a variety of SD-WAN deployment models, each of which solves a different WAN problem, so it’s important to assess your organization’s requirements and capabilities to ensure you build an architecture that meets your needs. It’s also critical to consider the scalability, adaptability, security, and resilience of your SD-WAN deployment to prevent headaches down the road. 

For example, using a vendor-neutral platform like Nodegrid to host SD-WAN allows you to easily expand your branch networking capabilities with third-party software for automation, security, monitoring, troubleshooting, and more without deploying additional hardware, allowing you to easily scale and adapt to changing business requirements. Nodegrid also consolidates branch functions like routing, switching, out-of-band serial console management, SD-WAN management, and SASE network security in a single device for cost-effective branch deployments. Plus, Nodegrid enables isolated management infrastructure that’s resilient to threats and provides a safe recovery environment from ransomware attacks and network failures. 

Ready to get started on your SD-WAN deployment?

Nodegrid unifies control over mixed-vendor hardware and software solutions across the enterprise network architecture for efficient, streamlined SD-WAN management. Request a free demo to learn more.

Request a Demo

PCI DSS 4.0 Requirements

Businessman,Using,Virtual,Touch,Screen,Clicks,Abbreviation:,Pci,Dss.,Concept
The Security Standards Council (SSC) of the Payment Card Industry (PCI) released the version 4.0 update of the Data Security Standard (DSS) in March 2022. PCI DSS 4.0 applies to any organization in any country that accepts, handles, stores, or transmits cardholder data. This standard defines cardholder data as any personally identifiable information (PII) associated with someone’s credit or debit card. The risks for PCI DSS 4.0 noncompliance include fines, reputational damage, and potentially lost business, so organizations must stay up to date with all recent changes.

The new requirements cover everything from protecting cardholder data to implementing user access controls, zero trust security measures, and frequent penetration (pen) testing. Each major requirement defined in the updated PCI DSS 4.0 is summarized below, with tables breaking down the specific compliance stipulations and providing tips or best practices for meeting them.

Citation: The PCI DSS v4.0

PCI DSS 4.0 requirements and best practices

Every PCI DSS 4.0 requirement starts with a stipulation that the processes and mechanisms for implementation are clearly defined and understood. The best practice involves updating policy and process documents as soon as possible after changes occur, such as when business goals or technologies evolve, and communicating changes across all relevant business units.

Jump to the other requirements below:

Build and maintain a secure network and systems

Requirement 1: Install and maintain network security controls

Network security controls include firewalls and other security solutions that inspect and control network traffic. PCI DSS 4.0 requires organizations to install and properly configure network security controls to protect payment card data.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Network security controls (NSCs) are configured and maintained.

Validate network security configurations before deployment and use configuration management to track changes and prevent configuration drift.

Network access to and from the cardholder data environment (CDE) is restricted.

Monitor all inbound traffic to the CDE, even from trusted networks, and, when possible, use explicit “deny all” firewall rules to prevent accidental gaps.

Network connections between trusted and untrusted networks are controlled.

Implement a DMZ that manages connections between untrusted networks and public-facing resources on the trusted network.

Risks to the CDE from computing devices that can connect to both untrusted networks and the CDE are mitigated.

Use security controls like endpoint protection and firewalls to protect devices from Internet-based attacks and zero-trust and network segmentation to prevent lateral movement to CDEs.

Requirement 2: Apply secure configurations to all system components

Attackers often compromise systems using known default passwords or old, forgotten services. PCI DSS 4.0 requires organizations to properly configure system security settings and reduce the attack surface by turning off unnecessary software, services, and accounts.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

System components are configured and managed securely.

Continuously check for vendor-default user accounts and security configurations and ensure all administrative access is encrypted using strong cryptographic protocols.

Wireless environments are configured and managed securely.

Apply the same security standards consistently across wired and wireless environments, and change wireless encryption keys whenever someone leaves the organization.

Protect account data

Requirement 3: Protect stored account data

Any payment account data an organization stores must be protected by methods such as encryption and hashing. Organizations should also limit account data storage unless it’s necessary and, when possible, truncate cardholder data.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Storage of account data is kept to a minimum.

Use data retention and disposal policies to configure an automated, programmatic procedure to locate and remove unnecessary account data.

Sensitive authentication data (SAD) is not stored after authorization.

Review data sources to ensure that the full contents of any track, card verification code, and PIN/PIN blocks are not retained after the authorization process is completed.

Access to displays of full primary account number (PAN) and ability to copy cardholder data are restricted.

Use role-based access control (RBAC) to limit PAN access to individuals with a defined need and use the masking approach to display only the number of digits needed for a specific function.

PAN is secured wherever it is stored.

Render PAN unreadable using one-way hashing with a randomly generated secret key, truncation, index tokens, and strong cryptography with secure key management.

Cryptographic keys used to protect stored account data are secured.

Manage cryptographic keys with a centralized key management system that’s PCI DSS 4.0 compliant to restrict access to key-encrypting keys and store them separately from data-encrypting keys.

Where cryptography is used to protect stored account data, key management processes and procedures covering all aspects of the key lifecycle are defined and implemented.

Use a key management solution that simplifies or automates key replacement for old or compromised keys.

Requirement 4: Protect cardholder data with strong cryptography during transmission over open, public networks

While requirement 3 applies to stored card data, requirement 4 outlines stipulations for protecting cardholder data in transit.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

PAN is protected with strong cryptography during transmission.

Encrypt PAN over both public and internal networks and apply strong cryptography at both the data level and the session level.

Maintain a vulnerability management program

Requirement 5: Protect all systems and networks from malicious software

Organizations must take steps to prevent malicious software (a.k.a., malware) from infecting the network and potentially exposing cardholder data.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Malware is prevented, or detected and addressed.

Use a combination of network-based controls, host-based controls, and endpoint security solutions; supplement signature-based tools with AI/ML-powered detection.

Anti-malware mechanisms and processes are active, maintained, and monitored.

Update tools and signature databases as soon as possible and prevent end-users from disabling or altering anti-malware controls.

Anti-phishing mechanisms protect users against phishing attacks.

Use a combination of anti-phishing approaches, including anti-spoofing controls, link scrubbers, and server-side anti-malware.

Requirement 6: Develop and maintain secure systems and software

Development teams should follow PCI-compliant processes when writing and validating code. Additionally, install all appropriate security patches immediately to prevent malicious actors from exploiting known vulnerabilities in systems and software.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Bespoke and custom software are developed securely.

Use manual or automatic code reviews to search for undocumented features, validate that third-party libraries are used securely, analyze insecure code structures, and check for logical vulnerabilities.

Security vulnerabilities are identified and addressed.

Use a centralized patch management solution to automatically notify teams of known vulnerabilities and pending updates.

Public-facing web applications are protected against attacks.

Use automatic vulnerability security assessment tools that include specialized web scanners that analyze web application protection.

Changes to all system components are managed securely.

Use a centralized source code version management solution to track, approve, and roll back changes.

Implement strong access control measures

Requirement 7: Restrict access to system components and cardholder data by business need-to-know

This PCI DSS 4.0 requirement aims to limit who and what has access to sensitive cardholder data and CDEs to prevent malicious actors from gaining access through a compromised, over-provisioned account. “Need to know” means that only accounts with a specific need should have access to sensitive resources; it’s often applied using the “least-privilege” approach, which means only granting accounts the specific privileges needed to perform a job role.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Access to system components and data is appropriately defined and assigned.

Use RBAC to provide accounts with access privileges based on their job functions (e.g., ‘customer service agent’ or ‘warehouse manager’) rather than on an individual basis.

Access to system components and data is managed via an access control system.

Use a centralized identity and access management (IAM) system to manage access across the enterprise, including branches, edge computing sites, and the cloud.

Requirement 8: Identify users and authenticate access to system components

Organizations must establish and prove the identity of any users attempting to access CDEs or sensitive data. This requirement is core to the zero trust security methodology which is designed to limit the scope of data access and theft once an attacker has already compromised an account or system.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

User identification and related accounts for users and administrators are strictly managed throughout an account’s lifecycle.

Use an account lifecycle management solution to streamline account discovery, provisioning, monitoring, and deactivation.

Strong authentication for users and administrators is established and managed.

Replace relatively weak passwords/passphrases with stronger authentication factors like hardware tokens or biometrics.

Multi-factor authentication (MFA) is implemented to secure access into the CDE.

MFA should also protect access to management interfaces on isolated management infrastructure (IMI) to prevent attackers from controlling the CDE.

MFA systems are configured to prevent misuse.

Secure the MFA system itself with strong authentication and validate MFA configurations before deployment to ensure it requires two different forms of authentication and does not allow any access without a second factor.

Use of application and system accounts and associated authentication factors is strictly managed.

Whenever possible, disable interactive login on system and application accounts to prevent malicious actors from logging in with them.

Requirement 9: Restrict physical access to cardholder data

Malicious actors could gain access to cardholder data by physically interacting with payment devices or tampering with the hardware infrastructure that stores and processes that data. These PCI DSS 4.0 requirements outline how to prevent physical data access.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Physical access controls manage entry into facilities and systems containing cardholder data.

Use logical or physical controls to prevent unauthorized users from connecting to network jacks and wireless access points within the CDE facility.

Physical access for personnel and visitors is authorized and managed.

Require visitor badges and an authorized escort for any third parties accessing the CDE facility, and keep an accurate log of when they enter and exit the building.

Media with cardholder data is securely stored, accessed, distributed, and destroyed.

Do not allow portable media containing cardholder data to leave the secure facility unless absolutely necessary.

Point of interaction (POI) devices are protected from tampering and unauthorized substitution.

Use a centralized, vendor-neutral asset management system to automatically discover and track all POI devices in use across the organization.

Use of application and system accounts and associated authentication factors is strictly managed.

Whenever possible, disable interactive login on system and application accounts to prevent malicious actors from logging in with them.

Regularly monitor and test networks

Requirement 10: Log and monitor all access to system components and cardholder data

User activity logging and monitoring will help prevent, detect, and mitigate CDE breaches. PCI DSS 4.0 requires organizations to collect, protect, and review audit logs of all user activities in the CDE.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Audit logs are implemented to support the detection of anomalies and suspicious activity, and the forensic analysis of events.

Use a user and entity behavior analytics (UEBA) solution to monitor user activity and detect suspicious behavior with machine learning algorithms.

Audit logs are protected from destruction and unauthorized modifications.

Never store audit logs in public-accessible locations; use strong RBAC and least-privilege policies to limit access.

Audit logs are reviewed to identify anomalies or suspicious activity.

Use an AIOps tool to analyze audit logs, detect anomalous activity, and automatically triage and notify teams of issues.

Audit log history is retained and available for analysis.

Retain audit logs for at least 12 months in a secure storage location; keep the last three months of logs immediately accessible to aid in breach resolution.

Time-synchronization mechanisms support consistent time settings across all systems.

Use NTP to synchronize clocks across all systems to help with breach mitigation and post-incident forensics.

Failures of critical security control systems are detected, reported, and responded to promptly.

Use AIOps to automatically detect, triage, and respond to security incidents. AIOps also provides automatic root-cause analysis (RCA) for faster incident resolution.

Requirement 11: Test security of systems and network regularly

Researchers and attackers continuously discover new vulnerabilities in systems and software, so organizations must frequently test network components, applications, and processes to ensure that in-place security controls are still adequate. ge changes; ensure alerts are monitored.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Wireless access points are identified and monitored, and unauthorized wireless access points are addressed.

Use a wireless analyzer to detect rogue access points.

External and internal vulnerabilities are regularly identified, prioritized, and addressed.

PCI DSS 4.0 requires internal and external vulnerability scans at least once every three months, but performing them more often is encouraged if your network is complex or changes frequently.

External and internal penetration testing is regularly performed, and exploitable vulnerabilities and security weaknesses are corrected.

Work with a PCI DSS-approved vendor to perform external and internal penetration testing; conduct pen testing on network segmentation controls.

Network intrusions and unexpected file changes are detected and responded to.

Use AI-powered, next-generation firewalls (NGFWs) with enhanced detection algorithms and automatic incident response capabilities.

Unauthorized changes on payment pages are detected and responded to.

Use anti-skimming technology like file integrity monitoring (FIM) to detect unauthorized payment page changes; ensure alerts are monitored.

Maintain an information security policy

Requirement 12: Support information security with organizational policies and programs

The final requirement is to implement information security policies and programs to support the processes described above and get everyone on the same page about their responsibilities regarding cardholder data privacy.

Stipulations for Compliance

Best Practices

Acceptable use policies for end-user technologies are defined and implemented.

Enforce usage policies with technical controls capable of locking users out of systems, applications, or devices if they violate these policies.

Risks to the cardholder data and environment are formally identified, evaluated, and managed.

Use a centralized patch management system to monitor firmware and software versions, detect changes that may increase risk, and deploy updates to fix vulnerabilities.

PCI DSS compliance is managed.

Service providers must assign executive responsibility for managing PCI DSS 4.0 compliance.

PCI DSS scope is documented and validated.

Frequently validate PCI DSS scope by evaluating the CDE and all connected systems to determine if coverage should be expanded.

Security awareness education is an ongoing activity.

Require all users to take security awareness training upon hire and every year afterwards; it’s also recommended to provide refresher training when someone transfers into a role with more access to sensitive data.

Personnel are screened to reduce risks from insider threats.

In addition to screening new hires, conduct additional screening when someone moves into a role with greater access to the CDE.

Risk to information assets associated with third-party service provider (TPSP) relationships is managed.

Thoroughly analyze the risk of working with third-parties based on their reporting practices, breach history, incident response procedures, and PCI DSS validation.

Third-party service providers (TPSPs) support their customers’ PCI DSS compliance.

Require TPSPs to provide their PCI DSS Attestation of Compliance (AOC) to demonstrate their compliance status.

Suspected and confirmed security incidents that could impact the CDE are responded to immediately.

Create a comprehensive incident response plan that designates roles to key stakeholders.

Isolate your CDE and management infrastructure with Nodegrid

The Nodegrid out-of-band (OOB) management platform from ZPE Systems isolates your control plane and provides a safe environment for cardholder data, management infrastructure, and ransomware recovery. Our vendor-neutral, Gen 3 OOB solution allows you to host third-party tools for automation, security, troubleshooting, and more for ultimate efficiency.

Ready to know more about PCI DSS 4.0 Requirements?

Learn how to meet PCI DSS 4.0 requirements for network segmentation and security by downloading our isolated management infrastructure (IMI) solution guide.
Download the Guide

Cyberthreats are Soaring: ZPE Systems Urges Immediate Action with Gen 3 Console Servers to Thwart Breaches

Press Release Complete EOL replacement solution

Organizations using end-of-life console servers must reduce their vulnerability exposure and secure their infrastructure comprehensively by using ZPE’s console servers, installation services and configuration engineering. 

Fremont, CA, May 2, 2024 — As cyberattacks continue to rise, ZPE Systems, a leader in network management infrastructure, recently acquired by Legrand, is urging organizations to  transition to Generation 3 console servers as part of their security strategies. With other well-known infrastructure providers discontinuing support for serial consoles already in use within data centers, communication networks and other commercial and industrial environments, the need to upgrade is paramount.    

Console servers are the backbone of remote IT management, providing essential access to network devices and servers. However, using discontinued console servers poses significant security risks. Outdated firmware may contain known vulnerabilities that enable cyber attackers to infiltrate critical systems, causing costly data breaches and operational disruptions. 

Despite these substantial risks, many organizations hesitate to replace their outdated infrastructure, citing budget constraints, labor costs and concerns about infrastructure disruption. Arnaldo Zimmermann, cofounder of ZPE Systems, highlights this dilemma, saying, “Organizations face financial constraints when considering hardware upgrades, especially when existing infrastructure seems to be working fine. When you consider the capex, labor costs and time it takes to physically install and configure new equipment, it’s easy to see why organizations say, ‘if it’s not broken, don’t fix it.’”  

To address these challenges, ZPE Systems now offers a comprehensive solution designed to alleviate budgetary concerns and streamline the replacement process:

1. New Cost-Effective Replacement Options

ZPE’s Nodegrid devices enable organizations to secure their management infrastructure with new budget-friendly, Gen 3 console servers. These range in cost from premium options to small yet powerful, budget-friendly units.

2. New Professional Installation & Recycling Services

As needed, ZPE Systems offers solutions for physical installation process and recycling of old equipment, minimizing downtime and ensuring environmental responsibility. ZPE connects organizations to a network of trusted partners including ByteBridge, Mirapath, Trace3, and others.

3. New Tailored Configuration Services

ZPE’s engineers provide customized configuration services to transfer the old configuration to new systems and optimize the performance and security of the new console servers. 

“There’s a lot of friction in upgrading,” adds Koroush Saraf, VP of Products and Marketing at ZPE Systems. “We’ve heard of customers using outdated devices for years, who won’t replace because they just don’t have the time, money or manpower. Our goal is to remove that friction, streamlining the transition process and empowering organizations to enhance their security posture without the added burden.”  

By utilizing Gen 3 console servers from ZPE, customers benefit from 3rd party security validated firmware that addresses Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVEs) as well as hardware security features designed to mitigate cybersecurity threats. Organizations can safeguard their assets, protect sensitive data, and maintain operational continuity in an increasingly volatile digital landscape. 

 

Explore this comprehensive solution using the link below

Explore the hardware options, trusted partner network, and configuration services by clicking the link. You can also get hands-on with this solution at RSA Conference next week. Click the link for details and to get ZPE’s special code that unlocks your free pass.

Cisco 4351 EOL Replacement Guide

A photo of the NSR, ZPE’s replacement option for the Cisco ISR 4431 EOL models.
The Cisco 4351 comes from the Integrated Services Router (ISR) product line of enterprise branch WAN solutions. The ISR 4351 works with Cisco’s software-defined wide area networking (SD-WAN) solution and the Cisco Digital Network Architecture (Cisco DNA) infrastructure management platform. It has a modular design that uses removable Network Interface Modules (NIMs) to extend its capabilities, for example, adding out-of-band (OOB) serial console management for up to 60 devices. Cisco announced end-of-life (EOL) dates for the entire ISR 4300 product line in 2022, and the 4351 is already past the end-of-sale and last ship dates. This guide compares Cisco 4351 EOL replacement options and discusses the innovative features and capabilities offered by modern, Gen 3 branch networking solutions. Click here for a list of Cisco ISR 4351 EOL products and replacement SKUs.

Upcoming Cisco ISR 4351 EOL dates

  • November 6, 2024 – End of routine failure analysis, end of new service attachment
  • August 31, 2025 – End of software maintenance releases and bug fixes
  • February 5, 2028 – End of service contract renewal
  • November 30, 2028 – Last date of support.

Looking to replace a different Cisco EOL model? Read our guides Cisco ISR 4431 EOL Replacement Guide and Cisco ISR EOL Replacement Options.

Cisco 4351 EOL replacement options

Cisco ISR 4351 (EOL)

Cisco Catalyst C8300

Nodegrid NSR

Out-of-band (OOB) management

Gen 1 OOB

Gen 2 OOB

Gen 3 OOB

Extensibility

Integrates with Cisco partners only

Integrates with Cisco partners only

Supports virtualization, containers, and integrations

Automation

• Policy-based automation

• Cloud-based automated device provisioning (ZTP)

• Automated deployment of network services (Cisco DNA)

• Policy-based automation

• Cloud-based automated device provisioning (ZTP)

• Automated deployment of network services (Cisco DNA)

• Zero Touch Provisioning (ZTP) via LAN/DHCP, WAN/ZPE Cloud, USB

• Auto-discovery via network scan and custom probes

• Integrated orchestration and automation:

  ◦ Puppet

  ◦ Chef

  ◦ Ansible

  ◦ RESTful

  ◦ ZPE Cloud

  ◦ Nodegrid Manager

Security

• Intrusion prevention

• Cisco Umbrella Branch

• Encrypted traffic analytics

• IPSec tunnels

• DMVPN

• FlexVPN

• GETVPN

• Content filtering

• NAT

• Zone-based firewall

• Intrusion prevention

• Cisco Umbrella Branch

• Encrypted traffic analytics

• IPSec tunnels

• DMVPN

• FlexVPN

• GETVPN

• Content filtering

• NAT

• Zone-based firewall

• Edgified, hardened device with BIOS protection, TPM 2.0, UEFI Secure Boot, Signed OS, Self-Encrypted Disk (SED), Geofencing

• X.509 SSH certificate support, 4096-bit encryption keys

• SDLC validated by Synopsys to eliminate CVEs and vulnerabilities from third-party integrations

• Selectable cryptographic protocols for SSH and HTTPS (TLSv1.3)

• SSL VPN (Client and Server)

• IPSec, WireGuard, strongSwan with support for multi-sites

• Local, AD/LDAP, RADIUS, TACACS+, and Kerberos authentication

• SAML support via Duo, Okta, Ping Identity

• Local, backup-user authentication support

• User-access lists per port

• Fine grain and role-based access control (RBAC)

• Firewall - IP packet and security filtering, IP forwarding support

• Two-factor authentication (2FA) with RSA and Duo

Hardware Services

• Serial console ports

• USB console ports

• IP management ports

• Voice functionality

• Compute module

• Serial console ports

• USB console ports

• Voice functionality

• Serial console ports

• USB console ports

• IP management ports

• PDU management

• IPMI device management

• (Optional) Compute module

• (Optional) Storage module

Network services

• Cisco SD-WAN software

• WAN optimization

• AppNAV

• Application visibility and control

• Multicast

• Overlay Transport Virtualization (OTV)

• Ethernet VPN (EVPNoMPLS)

• IPv6 support

• Cisco SD-WAN software

• WAN optimization

• AppNAV

• Application visibility and control

• Multicast

• Overlay Transport Virtualization (OTV)

• Ethernet VPN (EVPNoMPLS)

• IPv6 support

• IPv4 / IPv6 Support

• Embedded Layer 2 Switching

• VLAN

• Layer 3 Routing

• BGP

• OSPF

• RIP

• QoS

• DHCP (Client and Server)

Operating System

Cisco IOS

Cisco IOS

Built-in x86-64bit Linux Kernel Nodegrid OS

CPU

Multi-Core processor

Multi-Core processor

Intel x86-64 Multi-Core

Storage

4GB-8GB Flash memory

16GB M.2 SSD storage

32GB FLASH (mSATA SSD) (Upgradeable) Self-Encrypted Drive (SED)

RAM

4GB-8GB DRAM

8GB DRAM

8GB DDR DRAM (Upgradeable)

Size

2RU

2RU

1RU

The Cisco Catalyst C8300

Cisco recommends replacing the 4351 with the Catalyst C8300, but this platform does not go far enough to improve upon the limitations of the EOL model. For instance, both the ISR 4351 and the Catalyst C8300 replacement models are 2RU devices, making them too large for some branch and edge deployment use cases where space is limited. Additionally, while both platforms integrate with some of Cisco’s third-party partners (like ThousandEyes), Cisco is a closed ecosystem that may not support all the management, automation, and security tools needed to support an enterprise branch. Additionally, Cisco’s DNA software may not be able to control mixed-vendor infrastructure, leaving critical coverage gaps.

The Nodegrid Net SR (NSR)

A diagram showing all the capabilities of the Nodegrid NSR. ZPE Systems offers a range of enterprise branch network management solutions called Nodegrid that serve as an upgrade to Cisco 4351 EOL models. In particular, the Nodegrid Net Services Router (NSR) makes an ideal 4351 replacement due to its modular design, which can be extended with expansion modules for functionality like edge compute, PoE, USB OCP debug, and third-generation (or Gen 3) out-of-band management. Gen 3 OOB allows teams to deploy third-party automation and orchestration workflows over the OOB network to streamline branch provisioning, management, and recovery. Gen 3 OOB ensures 24/7 remote access to branch infrastructure even during network outages, provides a safe environment to recover from ransomware and other breaches, and keeps resource-intensive management workflows from bogging down the production network.

Want to see how Nodegrid stacks up against Cisco’s 4351 EOL replacement options? Click here to download the services routers comparative matrix.

Pictures of the compute module and Ethernet PoE module for the Nodegrid NSR. All Nodegrid solutions are completely vendor-neutral, integrating with or even directly hosting third-party software and extending complete visibility and control to legacy and mixed-vendor infrastructure. Nodegrid is essentially a branch-in-a-box, allowing companies to deploy infrastructure automation, network orchestration, branch security, and more on a single device that’s 1RU or smaller. Plus, this entire toolkit is available on an isolated, out-of-band network, ensuring remote teams have 24/7 access to keep business operating even during outages and ransomware attacks for superior network resilience.

Ready to replace your Cisco 4351 EOL solutions?

Nodegrid delivers vendor-neutral, branch-in-a-box solutions that streamline remote infrastructure management while improving network resilience. See our Cisco 4351 EOL replacement SKUs below or contact ZPE Systems for help choosing the right Nodegrid solution for your business.

Contact us

 

Cisco 4351 EOL replacement SKUs

Cisco 4351 EOL Product SKUs

In-Scope Features

Nodegrid Replacement Product SKUs

ISR4351-AX/K9

ISR4351-DNA

ISR4351-PM20

ISR4351-SEC/K9

ISR4351/K9

ISR4351-V/K9

ISR4351-VSEC/K9

Serial Console Module, Routing, 16 serial ports

ZPE-NSR-816-DAC with 1 x 16 port serial module 1 x ZPE-NSR-16SRL-EXPN

ISR4351-AX/K9

ISR4351-DNA

ISR4351-PM20

ISR4351-SEC/K9

ISR4351/K9

ISR4351-V/K9

ISR4351-VSEC/K9

Serial Console Module, Routing, 32 serial ports

ZPE-NSR-816-DAC with 2 x 16 port serial module 2 x ZPE-NSR-16SRL-EXPN

ISR4351-AX/K9

ISR4351-DNA

ISR4351-PM20

ISR4351-SEC/K9

ISR4351/K9

ISR4351-V/K9

ISR4351-VSEC/K9

Serial Console Module, Routing, 48 serial ports

ZPE-NSR-816-DAC with 3 x 16 port serial module 3 x ZPE-NSR-16SRL-EXPN

ISR4351-AX/K9

ISR4351-DNA

ISR4351-PM20

ISR4351-SEC/K9

ISR4351/K9

ISR4351-V/K9

ISR4351-VSEC/K9

Serial Console Module, Routing, 60 serial ports

ZPE-NSR-816-DAC with 4 x 16 port serial module 4 x ZPE-NSR-16SRL-EXPN

80 serial port option – no Cisco equivalent

Serial Console Module, Routing, 80 serial ports

ZPE-NSR-816-DAC with 5 x 16 port serial module 5 x ZPE-NSR-16SRL-EXPN

Opengear Alternatives for the OM2200 and OM1200

NSRSTACK2-1
The Opengear Operations Manager is a series of NetOps console servers providing out-of-band remote access to manage remote network infrastructure in data center, edge, and branch deployments. There are a few reasons to consider alternative options, including a lack of 3rd-party integrations, 5G support, and gateway routing capabilities. This blog goes over the pros and cons of the Operations Manager solutions before discussing Opengear alternatives that provide greater automation, orchestration, and security features as well as all-in-one branch networking capabilities.

Executive summary

  • Opengear’s Operations Manager (OM) appliances are NetOps console servers providing out-of-band (OOB) management for remote network infrastructure.
  • While OM appliances provide some automation capabilities, especially with the upgraded Automation Edition, they offer limited third-party integrations and end-device automation features.
  • The OM2200 and OM1200 both lack integrated branch gateway functionality and have limited security features overall.
  • The Nodegrid platform from ZPE Systems overcomes these limitations with vendor-neutral OOB serial consoles and branch services routers.
  • Nodegrid enables end-to-end automation through end-device ZTP and unlimited third-party integrations with leading tools like Ansible and Chef.
  • Nodegrid also consolidates data center and branch networking functionality like gateway routing, 5G cellular failover, and security to provide all-in-one solutions.

Reviewing the Opengear Operations Manager platform

Operations Manager (or OM) is Opengear’s line of NetOps console servers. OM appliances come with Smart OOBTM for out-of-band management, including automated port discovery and VLAN support. Opengear’s x86 Lighthouse platform supports Python scripts and Docker container deployments for NetOps automation. Lighthouse also supports over 100 power vendors’ equipment, allowing it to monitor and control UPS batteries, PDU outlets, and power load balancing. It’s important to note that, while the standard (Enterprise) edition of Lighthouse supports Python and Docker, customers must upgrade to the Automation edition for zero-touch provisioning (ZTP) or other third-party automation integrations. Additionally, OM solutions do not support 2FA or SAML authentication.

Opengear OM2200

The Opengear OM2200 Operations Manager model is designed for data center and high-density use cases. It features 16, 32, 48 serial and 24 serial/Ethernet mixed port configuration options, with an optional global LTE-A Pro cellular module. The OM2200 provides five regional options for dual AC power as well as a dual DC power cord model.

Click here to see a complete Opengear OM2200 Operations Manager product SKUs list.

OM2200 Pros:

  • Plenty of RAM and storage space
  • Many options for power and serial port configurations
  • Uniquely broad support for 3rd-party power equipment
  • Some NetOps automation capabilities

OM2200 Cons:

  • Requires upgraded software licenses for ZTP and most 3rd-party automation
  • No 2FA or SAML 2.0 support
  • No managed USB serial ports
  • No 5G support

Opengear OM1200

The Opengear OM1200 Operations Manager model is meant for small edge deployments. The compact chassis supports 4 serial, 8 serial, and 8 serial/8 Ethernet port combinations. It provides OOB and failover access via dual Ethernet (SFP Fiber is available on the 4E and 8E models) as well as an optional global LTE-A Pro cellular module.

Click here to see a full list of Opengear OM1200 Operations Manager product SKUs.

OM1200 Pros:

  • Compact size
  • Cost-effective range of port configurations
  • Supports 3rd-party power equipment, Docker, and Python

OM1200 Cons:

  • Requires upgraded software licenses for ZTP and most 3rd-party automation
  • No 2FA or SAML 2.0 support
  • It doesn’t have gateway routing/SD-WAN capabilities
  • No 5G support

Opengear Operations Manager limitations

Both the OM2200 and OM1200 models suffer from similar limitations regarding automation, especially with the base version of the Lighthouse software. Even the upgraded Automation Edition, which unlocks ZTP and RESTful APIs, doesn’t provide much automation for end devices beyond running Python playbooks. This limits operational efficiency, slows down new deployments, and impedes the team’s ability to quickly rebuild core infrastructure after a failure or ransomware attack. Another issue with the OM1200, in particular, is that while its compact size will save space in your edge data center and branch office rack, it’s still a single-purpose device. That means you still need to purchase separate solutions for gateway routing, switching, and/or edge compute. These additional devices take up space, cost extra money, and require time to configure and manage.

Opengear alternatives from ZPE Systems

ZPE Systems provides an alternative option for NetOps-enabled OOB console servers called the Nodegrid solution. All Nodegrid devices run on the open, Linux-based, x86 Nodegrid OS which supports VMs and Docker containers to run your choice of third-party automation, software-defined networking/SD-WAN, and security applications. Nodegrid’s robust, onboard security protects lost or stolen devices with features like TPM 2.0, encrypted SSD, UEFI BIOS, secure boot, and geofencing. Nodegrid can also extend ZTP and other automation to legacy and mixed-vendor end devices for end-to-end network infrastructure automation. Try ZPE’s product selector to see which of Nodegrid’s serial consoles or integrated branch routers is right for your deployment. Below, we review the two models that serve as direct replacements for the Opengear OM1200 and OM2200 solutions.

Nodegrid Serial Console Plus (NSCP)

The Nodegrid Serial Console Plus (NSCP) is an alternative to the OM2200 for data center and high-density deployments. The NSCP connects 16, 32, 48, or 96 (Patent No. 9,905,980) serial devices, all in a standard 1U rackmount chassis. Dual SFP+, dual Gigabit Ethernet, and optional Wi-FI and 4G/5G LTE modules provide secure Gen 3 OOB management access and failover, ensuring blazing fast speeds and high performance. Plus, the NSCP comes with two managed USB 3.0 ports for additional flexibility.

Click here to see a complete list of Nodegrid NSCP product SKUs.

Nodegrid Net Services Router (NSR)

The Nodegrid Net Services Router (NSR) is an alternative to the OM1200 for edge data center and branch office use cases. The NSR is a modular, compact device that can deliver gateway routing, switching, serial console, and compute capabilities all in a single appliance. Gen 3 OOB and network failover are provided out of the box via dual SFP+ and dual Gigabit Ethernet ports, with optional modules for WiFi and dual-SIM 5G/4G LTE. Additional NSR modules include:

  • 16-port GbE Ethernet
  • Storage
  • 16-port Serial (for console server capabilities)
  • 16-port USB serial
  • Compute
  • 8-port PoE+
  • M.2 Cellular/Wi-Fi/SATA
  • 16-port GbE Ethernet SFP
  • 8-port Ethernet SFP+

Click here to see a complete list of Nodegrid NSCP product SKUs.

Key takeaways:

While the OM1200 and OM2200 provide OOB management with some automation, they have serious limitations that negatively impact operational efficiency. Nodegrid is an Opengear alternative providing a vendor-neutral OOB management platform that delivers unlimited automation, enhanced security, and all-in-one networking for ultimate operational efficiency.

Trade in to get a discount on Opengear alternatives

If you’re ready to replace end-of-life devices from Opengear or other vendors, now’s your chance to get a discount. Visit our trade-in page to get your trade-in offer.
Get Trade-In Offer

See Nodegrid’s Opengear Alternatives in action

Reach out today to view a demo of Nodegrid’s Opengear alternatives in action.
Request a Demo

Opengear OM2200 – Product SKU’s:

OM2216

16 x Serial, 8GB RAM, 64GB SSD, 8 x USB 2.0, 2 x GbE/SFP Fiber

OM2216-AU

Dual AC – Australian power cord

OM2216-EU

Dual AC – European Union power cord

OM2216-JP

Dual AC – Japanese power cord

OM2216-UK

Dual AC – United Kingdom power cord

OM2216-US

Dual AC – United States power cord

OM2216-DDC

Dual DC power

OM2216-L-AU

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – AU power cord

OM2216-L-EU

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – EU power cord

OM2216-L-JP

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – JP power cord

OM2216-L-UK

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – UK power cord

OM2216-L-US

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – US power cord

OM-2216-DDC-L

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual DC power

 

OM2224-24E

24 x Serial, 24 x GbE, 8GB RAM, 64GB Flash

OM2224-24E-AU

1 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – Australian power cord

OM2224-24E-EU

1 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – European Union power cord

OM2224-24E-JP

1 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – Japanese power cord

OM2224-24E-UK

1 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – United Kingdom power cord

OM2224-24E-US

1 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – United States power cord

OM2224-24E-DDC

1 x GbE/SFP, Dual DC power

OM2224-24E-L-AU

1 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – AU power cord

OM2224-24E-L-EU

1 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – EU power cord

OM2224-24E-L-JP

1 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – JP power cord

OM2224-24E-L-UK

1 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – UK power cord

OM2224-24E-L-US

1 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – US power cord

OM2224-24E-DDC-L

1 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual DC power

OM2224-24E-10G-AU

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – AU power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-EU

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – EU power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-JP

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – JP power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-UK

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – UK power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-US

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – US power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-DDC

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual DC power

OM2224-24E-10G-L-AU

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – AU power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-L-EU

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – EU power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-L-JP

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – JP power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-L-UK

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – UK power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-L-US

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – US power cord

OM2224-24E-10G-DDC-L

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual DC power

 

OM2232

32 x Serial, 8GB RAM, 64GB SSD, 2 x GbE/SFP Fiber

OM2232-AU

Dual AC – Australian power cord

OM2232-EU

Dual AC – European Union power cord

OM2232-JP

Dual AC – Japanese power cord

OM2232-UK

Dual AC – United Kingdom power cord

OM2232-US

Dual AC – United States power cord

OM2232-DDC

Dual DC power

OM2232-L-AU

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – AU power cord

OM2232-L-EU

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – EU power cord

OM2232-L-JP

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – JP power cord

OM2232-L-UK

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – UK power cord

OM2232-L-US

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – US power cord

OM2232-DDC-L

Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual DC power

 

OM2248

48 x Serial, 8GB RAM, 64GB SSD

OM2248-AU

2 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – Australian power cord

OM2248-EU

2 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – European Union power cord

OM2248-JP

2 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – Japanese power cord

OM2248-UK

2 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – United Kingdom power cord

OM2248-US

2 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – United States power cord

OM2248-DDC

2 x GbE/SFP, Dual DC power

OM2248-L-AU

2 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – AU power cord

OM2248-L-EU

2 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – EU power cord

OM2248-L-JP

2 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – JP power cord

OM2248-L-UK

2 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – UK power cord

OM2248-L-US

2 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – US power cord

OM2248-DDC-L

2 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual DC power

OM2248-10G-AU

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – AU power cord

OM2248-10G-EU

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – EU power cord

OM2248-10G-JP

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – JP power cord

OM2248-10G-UK

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – UK power cord

OM2248-10G-US

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual AC – US power cord

OM2248-10G-DDC

10 x GbE/SFP, Dual DC power

OM2248-10G-L-AU

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – AU power cord

OM2248-10G-L-EU

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – EU power cord

OM2248-10G-L-JP

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – JP power cord

OM2248-10G-L-UK

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – UK power cord

OM2248-10G-L-US

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual AC – US power cord

OM2248-10G-DDC-L

10 x GbE/SFP, Global 4G LTE-A Pro cellular module, Dual DC power

Opengear OM1200 – Product SKU’s

OM1204

4 x Serial, 2GB RAM, 16GB Flash, 1 x GbE

OM1204-L

4 x Serial, 2GB RAM, 16GB Flash, 1 x GbE, Global 4G LTE

OM1204-4E

4 x Serial, 4 x GbE, 4GB RAM, 16GB Flash, 1 x GbE SFP 

OM1204-4E-L

4 x Serial, 4 x GbE, 4GB RAM, 16GB Flash, 1 x GbE SFP, Global 4G LTE 

OM1208

8 x Serial, 2GB RAM, 16GB Flash, 1 x GbE

OM1208-L

8 x Serial, 2GB RAM, 16GB Flash, 1 x GbE, Global 4G LTE

OM1208-8E

8 x Serial straight X2 pinout, 8 x GbE switch, 4GB RAM, 16GB SSD, 2 x USB 2.0, 2 x GbE/SFP Fiber

OM1208-8E-L

8 x Serial straight X2 pinout, 8 x GbE switch, 4GB RAM, 16GB SSD, 2 x USB 2.0, 2 x GbE/SFP Fiber, Global 4G LTE

Nodegrid Serial Console Plus – Product SKU’s

Nodegrid Serial Console Plus (NSCP)

4-Core Intel CPU, 4GB DDR4 RAM, 32GB SSD, 2 x SFP+, 2 x GbE, 2 x USB 3.0, 1 x HDMI, 1 x Console

NSCP-T16R-STND-SAC

16 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Single AC power

NSCP-T16R-STND-DAC

16 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Dual AC power

NSCP-T16R-STND-DDC

16 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Dual AC power

NSCP-T32R-STND-SAC

32 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Single AC power

NSCP-T32R-STND-DAC

32 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Dual AC power

NSCP-T32R-STND-DDC

32 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Dual DC power

NSCP-T48R-STND-SAC

48 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Single AC power

NSCP-T48R-STND-DAC

48 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Dual AC power

NSCP-T48R-STND-DDC

48 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Dual DC power

NSCP-T96R-STND-SAC

96 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Single AC power

NSCP-T96R-STND-DAC

96 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Dual AC power

NSCP-T96R-STND-DDC

96 x Cisco Rolled Serial, Dual DC power

Nodegrid Net SR – Product SKU’s

Nodegrid Net Services Router (NSR)

Multi-Core Intel CPU, On-board Switch, 8GB DDR4 RAM, 32GB MSATA, Hot-Swappable Fans, 2 x SFP+, 2 x GbE

NSR-TOP1-DAC

Dual AC power, 5 Slots support

NSR-BASE-DAC

Dual AC power, 3 Slots support

NSR-TOP1-SAC

Single AC power, 5 Slots support

NSR-BASE-SAC

Single AC power, 3 Slots support

NSR-TOP1-SAC-POE

Single AC and PoE, 5 Slots support

NSR-BASE-SAC-POE

Single AC and PoE, 3 Slots support

Expansion Cards

NSR-16ETH-EXPN

16 x GbE Ethernet expansion card

NSR-8ETH-POE-EXPN

8 x GbE Ethernet with PoE+ expansion card

NSR-16SRL-EXPN

16 x RJ45 Serial Rolled expansion card

NSR-16USB-EXPN

16 x USB Type A expansion card

NSR-8SFP-EXPN

8 x 10GbE SFP expansion card

NSR-DISK-EXPN

Storage expansion card

NSR-COMP-EXPN

Compute 4-core, 8GB DDR4, 32GB SATA expansion card

NSR-M2-EXPN

M.2/SATA Expansion Card

SD-WAN Leaders Analysis Report

Logos for the six SD-WAN leaders with a vs. in the middle
Gartner’s most recent Magic Quadrant for SD-WAN identified six vendors as leaders in the market. These vendors qualify as leaders due to numerous factors, including their influence in the market, a demonstrated ability to adapt to changing customer requirements and innovate to anticipate future needs, and solid SD-WAN product offerings that serve most use cases and verticals. This report uses Gartner’s Magic Quadrant and independent analysis to compare the six SD-WAN leaders based on their features, security, versatility, and other key factors.

Comparing SD-WAN leaders

Leading SD-WAN Vendor

Key Takeaways

Cisco

    • Cisco Catalyst SD-WAN (formerly Viptela) and Cisco Meraki SD-WAN products include SD-WAN appliances, integrated security, and centralized management and orchestration

    • Cisco has a proven track record of aligning its SD-WAN feature roadmap with the ever-changing needs of enterprise customers

    • Catalyst and Meraki are different products with entirely separate management platforms, reducing scalability and versatility

Fortinet

    • Fortinet Secure SD-WAN includes physical and virtual NGFW appliances, multi-cloud on-ramp access, and centralized orchestration

    • Fortinet’s SD-WAN offering is extensible with the addition of AI-powered security bundles for a single-vendor SASE solution

    • Fortinet’s limited support for third-party integrations creates vendor lock-in and prevents companies from deploying a unified, multi-vendor SASE solution

HPE (Aruba)

    • HPE’s Aruba EdgeConnect SD-WAN and Aruba EdgeConnect SD-Branch products include physical and virtual appliances with centralized management and orchestration

    • Aruba SD-WAN offerings include performance optimization, cloud on-ramping, and enhanced operational capabilities

    • SD-WAN and SD-Branch offerings target different use cases, which could cause confusion, though both are managed by the same Aruba Central platform

Palo Alto Networks

    • Palo Alto Network’s Prisma SD-WAN includes Instant-On Network (ION) edge appliances and centralized orchestration, while the PAN-OS branch firewall can be upgraded with limited SD-WAN capabilities

    • Prisma provides robust SD-WAN features like cloud on-ramp access and autonomous digital experience management

    • Each product is managed separately and comes with limitations to either security or SD-WAN functionality

Versa Networks

    • Versa Networks offers the on-premises Secure SD-WAN and cloud-based Versa Titan products, which include physical or virtual appliances and centralized orchestration

    • Versa Networks offers a robust SD-WAN feature set, including strong routing and application steering, cloud on-ramping, and integrated security

    • Versa’s high price point and limited geographic presence make it unsuitable for customers in certain regions

VMware

    • VMware VeloCloud SD-WAN includes edge appliances, optional gateway points of presence (POPs), and a cloud-based orchestrator

    • VeloCloud SD-WAN integrates with VMware’s SASE platform as well as other products for cloud security and AIOps

    • VMware SD-WAN lacks native SD-Branch functionality and offers fewer integrated security features for the standalone SD-WAN product

Cisco

Cisco offers two different SD-WAN products: Cisco Catalyst SD-WAN (formerly Viptela), which targets enterprise customers, and Cisco Meraki SD-WAN, which targets mid-size organizations with lean IT operations. Each product is an entirely separate offering managed by different software platforms, making it difficult for a customer to mix-and-match products to adapt to new use cases or start with Meraki and then scale up to Catalyst during an aggressive growth period.

Catalyst SD-WAN is an advanced solution with integrated security, support for cloud on-ramp access, and integrations with ThousandEyes for monitoring and analytics as well as Cisco SSE products for a single-vendor SASE solution. Meraki SD-WAN is a more streamlined option, offering unified management of Meraki infrastructure with integrated security, zero-touch provisioning, and support for machine learning analytics.

Cisco SD-WAN - Pro's
  • Catalyst SD-WAN offers advanced features like multi-cloud on-ramp access and SSE integrations
  • Meraki SD-WAN provides a more streamlined experience with features like zero-touch provisioning to simplify lean IT operations
  • Cisco’s SD-WAN feature roadmap typically aligns with the current and future needs of enterprise customers
  • Cisco SD-WAN - Con's
    • Catalyst and Meraki are separate products with different management platforms, making it more challenging to use both
    • Based on Gartner’s reported client interactions, Cisco’s customer experience rating is lower than other vendors in this category
    • Fortinet

      Fortinet’s Secure SD-WAN solutions run on FortiGate physical and virtual NGFW (next-generation firewall) appliances, tightly integrating networking and security in a consolidated platform. In addition to a centralized orchestrator, Fortinet SD-WAN includes zero-touch provisioning and multi-cloud on-ramp access. It also enables single-vendor SASE with the addition of optional, AI-powered security bundles. However, Fortinet’s limited third-party integrations create vendor lock-in and prevent customers from building a unified, customized, multi-vendor SASE solution.

      Fortinet SD-WAN - Pro's
      • Fortinet combines SD-WAN functionality with NGFW appliances for a tightly integrated, consolidated experience
      • Fortinet offers zero-touch provisioning and multi-cloud on-ramp access to further streamline SD-WAN operations
      • Fortinet enables single-vendor SASE with options for AI-powered security bundles
      • Fortineet SD-WAN - Con's
        • Fortinet has limited integrations with third-party SSE vendors, preventing customers from unifying their multi-vendor SASE deployment
        • Gartner reports that Fortinet’s customer experience rating is below average compared to other SD-WAN vendors in the Magic Quadrant
        • HPE (Aruba)

          HPE (Aruba) has two SD-WAN offerings: EdgeConnect SD-WAN, which is a standalone SD-WAN product, and EdgeConnect SD-Branch, which builds upon the SD-WAN platform by adding software-defined management for wired and wireless branch LANs. Both products run on physical and virtual NGFW appliances for integrated security functionality, and both are managed by the same central orchestrator. Additional features include multi-cloud on-ramp access, unified management of Aruba networking solutions, and integrations with Aruba SSE products for single-vendor SASE.

          It’s notable that HPE (Aruba) is one of only two vendors named as Gartner SD-WAN leaders for all six years of the SD-WAN Magic Quadrant’s existence – the other is VMware.

          HPE (Aruba) SD-WAN - Pro's
          • Aruba offers two tightly integrated products combining SD-WAN and NGFW functionality for converged networking
          • Aruba’s SD-Branch solution extends software-defined control and zero-trust security to wired and wireless branch LANs
          • Aruba’s products include multi-cloud on-ramp access and integrations with Aruba SSE for single-vendor SASE
          • HPE (Aruba) SD-WAN - Con's
            • Aruba’s two different SD-WAN offerings may confuse customers who are unfamiliar with SD-Branch technology
            • Gartner noted that Aruba’s geographic strategy lacked details, so it may not reach customers in all locations
            • Palo Alto Networks

              Palo Alto Networks offers a dedicated SD-WAN product called Prisma SD-WAN, as well as an SD-WAN upgrade for its PAN-OS branch NGFW solution.

              Prisma SD-WAN is part of Palo Alto’s Prisma SASE platform, which was one of the industry’s first complete, single-vendor SASE solutions. The SD-WAN component uses Palo Alto’s Instant-On Network (ION) edge appliances that include integrated, cloud-delivered security, AIOps, SD-Branch, cloud on-ramp access, and autonomous digital experience management (ADEM).

              Palo Alto’s SD-WAN plugin integrates with PAN-OS branch firewalls to provide an SD-WAN overlay with centralized orchestration. It uses separate management software (called Panorama) from the Prisma platform. Essentially, each SD-WAN product targets different use cases and has different limitations. Prisma offers more advanced SD-WAN functionality but weaker on-premises security features (though this can be addressed by hosting Prisma on hardened third-party devices), whereas the PAN-OS platform offers strong branch security features but a more basic SD-WAN overlay.

              Palo Alto Networks SD-WAN Pros
              • Prisma SD-WAN offers advanced features like cloud-delivered security, AIOps, SD-Branch, cloud on-ramp access, and ADEM
              • Palo Alto’s SD-WAN plugin for PAN-OS provides a simpler upgrade path for existing NGFW customers
              • Based on Gartner’s reporting client interactions and Peer Insights data, Palo Alto has an above-average customer experience rating
              • Palo Alto Networks SD-WAN Cons
                • Palo Alto customers must choose between robust SD-WAN with limited branch security or advanced on-premises security functionality with limited SD-WAN
                • Gartner clients reported that Palo Alto Prisma SD-WAN has higher pricing compared to other vendors
                • Versa Networks

                  Versa Networks provides two SD-WAN options, Versa Secure SD-WAN and Versa Titan, which are entirely separate platforms with different orchestrators. Versa Secure SD-WAN offers a fully-featured SD-WAN overlay including advanced features such as multi-cloud on-ramp access, AIOps, a wide range of integrated security functionality like CASB and NGFW, and automated zero-touch provisioning.

                  Versa Titan is a cloud-managed, single-vendor SASE platform for leaner IT operations, providing a basic SD-WAN overlay that’s tightly integrated with cloud-based security features. Titan is an entirely separate product offering and platform targeting an entirely different use case. It offers a more streamlined experience, and it’s more affordable than Versa Secure SD-WAN, according to Gartner analyst assessment and Peer Insights data.

                  Versa Networks SD-WAN Pros
                  • Versa Secure SD-WAN is packed with advanced networking and security features like multi-cloud on-ramp access, AIOps, integrated security, and application steering
                  • Versa Titan offers a streamlined, unified SASE platform with a basic SD-WAN overlay for lean IT operations
                  • Gartner is optimistic about Versa Networks’ product roadmap and ability to meet changing customer requirements
                  • Versa Networks SD-WAN Cons
                    • Based on information from Gartner analysts and Peer Insights data, Versa Secure SD-WAN has a higher-then-average price point in the industry
                    • Versa Networks lacks a strong global presence and may not reach customers in all regions or countries
                    • VMware

                      VMware offers the VeloCloud SD-WAN product, which includes edge networking appliances (physical and virtual), optional gateway points of presence (POPs), and a centralized, cloud-based orchestrator. The VMware Edge Cloud Orchestrator software also integrates with other VMware products like VeloCloud Web Security and the VMware Edge Intelligence AIOps platform. VMware’s SD-WAN offering is also part of VMware’s VeloCloud SASE solution, which uses security functionality from Symantec (owned by Broadcom, the same parent company as VMware).

                      However, the VeloCloud SD-WAN product itself lacks many of the advanced features natively available in competing solutions, such as integrated security and SD-Branch. Despite these limitations, VMware is the only other vendor besides HPE (Aruba) to achieve Gartner SD-WAN leader status for six consecutive years.

                      VMware SD-WAN Pros
                      • VMware VeloCloud SD-WAN includes optional features like gateway POPs and integrations with other VMware products for security and AIOps
                      • VeloCloud SD-WAN is part of VMware’s VeloCloud SASE solution that uses Symantec security features to deliver unified SASE
                      • VMware has a strong customer experience rating based on Gartner client interactions and Peer Insights data
                      • VMware SD-WAN Cons
                        • VMware VeloCloud SD-WAN lacks many of the advanced features natively offered by competing vendors, such as multi-cloud on-ramp access and SD-Branch
                        • The standalone VeloCloud SD-WAN product has limited integrated security functionality unless expanded with additional services
                        • A peek into the future of SD-WAN

                          Gartner’s SD-WAN Magic Quadrant predicted that by 2026, 60% of new SD-WAN purchases will be part of a single-vendor SASE solution, an increase of 45% from 2023. However, extensibility and vendor choice still factored into Gartner’s ratings of current SD-WAN leaders. Closed ecosystems with limited integrations prevent organizations from adapting to new use cases and changing requirements with the speed and agility needed to stay competitive.

                          Companies can avoid vendor lock-in by deploying vendor-neutral edge infrastructure that supports third-party SD-WAN and SASE solutions. For example, the Nodegrid platform from ZPE Systems provides powerful, consolidated branch networking functionality that integrates (or even directly runs) other vendors’ software for SD-WAN, security, AIOps, and more. Plus, Nodegrid provides out-of-band (OOB) management to ensure 24/7 remote management access and network resilience.

                          Deploy SD-WAN leaders with Nodegrid

                          Nodegrid provides a powerful, vendor-neutral foundation to simplify SD-WAN deployment and enable unlimited extensibility, future-proofing branch network operations. Request a free Nodegrid demo to see how it works with your chosen SD-WAN solution.

                          Get a Demo